How to tell if your hotel is strengthening a place, or extracting from it.
Read MoreHow to tell if your hotel is strengthening a place, or extracting from it.
Read MoreTravel has long been framed as an exchange. You arrive, you spend, the place benefits.
But that equation has started to fracture. Not all spending stays where it lands. Not all hotels are built to circulate value. Some are designed, very precisely, to capture it.
The difference is not always visible. But it is there, in the way a place operates, who it includes, and where the money ultimately goes.
You can usually feel it before you can explain it. The question is simple: does it behave like it belongs?
It shows up in small ways. In menus that reflect what’s grown nearby. In artwork that feels specific to the place, not sourced to fit a brief. In the way staff speak; whether there’s a natural ease, a familiarity with what sits beyond the hotel’s walls. And in whether you’re encouraged outward, pointed toward the town, or kept within the property’s orbit.
As Professor Suranga Silva puts it:
“These small details transform a hotel from a mere place to stay into an economic engine for its surroundings.”
Beyond what you see, there is a more structural question: where does the value end up?
Ownership plays a role, but not in the way it is often simplified. A locally owned hotel is not automatically beneficial. A foreign-owned one is not automatically extractive.
What matters is what happens to profit, and what sits beneath it.
“It is crucial to examine not just who owns it, but who benefits from it,” says Professor Suranga Silva.
A hotel that strengthens its surroundings tends to reinvest locally. It builds long-term relationships with suppliers. It grows alongside its environment, rather than using it as a backdrop.
An extractive model is different. Money moves quickly through the place, but not into it. Supply chains sit elsewhere. Decisions are made at a distance. Revenues are often routed through foreign bank accounts, with profits leaving the country as quickly as they arrive. The hotel operates in the destination, but not with it.
You won’t always see this directly. But you can sense its outcomes; in how much of the experience feels rooted, and how much feels imported.
Staffing is where the structure becomes visible.
Not just in who is employed, but in who holds influence. Who makes decisions? Who builds a career?
In a hotel that is contributing meaningfully to its local economy, local staff are present across the full structure of the business. Not just at the front of house, but in management, finance, operations, and the kitchen. This indicates there is movement over time. People stay, develop, and step into leadership.
Silva suggests paying attention to the simplest indicators. How long people have been there, whether managers are local, and whether there is a sense of continuity.
A hotel does not just employ people. It shapes what is possible for them.
If there is one place where a hotel’s economic model becomes tangible, it is in what it consumes.
Food is the clearest example. Not as a marker of authenticity, but as a map of relationships.
“The breakfast table is actually one of the best tests for the impact of hotels on local economy,” says Professor Suranga Silva.
A kitchen that is tied to its surroundings will shift with the seasons. It will reflect what is grown nearby, what is caught locally, and what is made within reach. The menu becomes a reflection of place, not just preference.
A more extractive system tends to standardise. Ingredients are sourced through centralised distributors. Consistency replaces specificity. What you eat could exist anywhere.
The same logic extends beyond food. To linens, furniture, building materials, and amenities. Each choice either anchors the hotel to its surroundings or disconnects it from them.
Over time, those choices accumulate. They determine whether a hotel supports an ecosystem, or bypasses it entirely.
Some of the most extractive models are also the most compelling on the surface.
In Sri Lanka’s boutique and luxury sector, there has been a rise in properties that offer a complete, contained experience. Architecturally striking, highly serviced, and deliberately self-sufficient.
But that self-sufficiency can come at a cost.
“It creates a sealed experience, where guests are discouraged from venturing into local markets or eating at local restaurants,” says Professor Suranga Silva.
Everything happens within the property. Dining, activities, retail, and even cultural programming. The guest has little reason to leave, and therefore little interaction with the surrounding economy.
This is not always framed negatively. It is often positioned as convenience or exclusivity. But structurally, it concentrates value in one place.
You can recognise it in the absence of references to what sits outside the gates. In the lack of a visible connection to nearby producers, guides, or businesses. In an experience that feels complete, but isolated.
Sustainability has become the language of modern hospitality. But language is easy to adopt.
What matters is whether it is backed by systems.
Credible sustainability tends to be specific. It is measured, audited, and disclosed. It tracks energy use, waste, sourcing, and emissions. It operates with accountability.
Frameworks like the Global Sustainable Tourism Council or Green Key require that level of rigour.
Without it, sustainability becomes narrative. A set of gestures that signal intent, but do not necessarily change outcomes.
Silva notes that visible acts of goodwill; donations, community projects, one-off initiatives can often sit alongside weak economic integration.
They are not meaningless. But they are not structural.
The real test is whether sustainability is embedded in how the hotel operates, not just how it presents itself.
For travellers trying to make better choices, instinct helps. You don’t need to dig into systems or ask difficult questions. Most of it is visible in how a place presents itself.
Look at who and what the hotel chooses to highlight. Does it mention local producers, guides, or the surrounding area, or does everything centre on the property itself?
Notice the food and experience it promises. Does it feel tied to where you are, or familiar in a way that could sit anywhere?
Pay attention to tone. Does the hotel position itself as part of a place, or as a destination in its own right?
These signals are rarely framed as answers, but they shape the reality behind them.
As Professor Suranga Silva suggests, the goal is not to find perfection, but to understand participation, whether a place is part of an economy or simply passing through it.
A hotel does not need to be perfect to contribute. But it does need to be connected.
To people. To place. To the systems that exist beyond its walls.
Because the real impact of a stay isn’t defined by your visit, but by what remains after you leave.
SHARE
Sign up for our newsletter